Australian govt report backs ban on domestic commercial surrogacy
by Michael Cook | 7 May 2016 |
A government report has backed calls for an international treaty on surrogacy and for uniform legislation within Australia banning commercial surrogacy.
A Senate committee tabled its conclusions this week. In a nutshell, it backs altruistic surrogacy, but not commercial surrogacy. In a society where marriage and the family are changing rapidly, with many children lacking genetic connections with parents, surrogacy can be a solution for infertile couples, it contends.
However, the report left a number of issues in the too-hard basket. The include changing birth certificates to include all people who could qualify as parents – genetic, gestational and intended and making use of commercial surrogates overseas illegal.
Research shows that about 250 children from commercial surrogacy arrangements are brought back to Australia every year. Australia is powerless to stop this, argues the committee. The best the government can do is to give advice about the dangers of offshore arrangements and the possibility of abusing the human rights of the women involved.
Everyone agrees that fundamental principle of surrogacy must be the “best interests of the child”. However, there is a stark division on what those are. Some people told the committee that surrogacy in any form could never be in the best interests of the child because it creates confusion about his or her identity and is inconsistent with the United Nations Convention of the Rights of the Child. Others declared that it could be consistent. The committee sat on the fence.
Another issue is reimbursement for “reasonable expenses” for altruistic surrogates. The committee backed “appropriate reimbursement”.
BioEdge was launched in 2001, in the week that President George W. Bush announced his administration's policy on human embryonic stem cell research. That fuelled a huge debate about a field of science which very few people had ever heard of, let alone thought deeply about. Ever since we've been chronicling the debates surrounding the ever-expanding empire of bioethics.
As we celebrate our 15th anniversary, we are also promoting a fund-raising drive over the next four weeks. The BioEdge newsletter is free, but it is increasingly expensive to produce. This year we are hoping to raise $15,000.
Cheers,
Michael Cook
Editor
BioEdge
| This week in BioEdge | |
by Xavier Symons | May 07, 2016
Policy analysts in the US and UK are calling for an augmentation of the decades-old 14-day embryo experimentation rule.by Michael Cook | May 07, 2016
Steep rise in end-stage psychiatric disorders and dementia.by Xavier Symons | May 07, 2016
Public health executives see a big positive in the US opioid tragedies – increased organ donation.by Xavier Symons | May 07, 2016
Here’s what a few bioethicists have to say.by Xavier Symons | May 07, 2016
Human beings are more likely to die in a mass extinction event than a car crash, according to a new report on existential risk.by Michael Cook | May 07, 2016
... but supports altruistic surrogacyby Michael Cook | May 07, 2016
Falun Gong supporters query government announcementsby Michael Cook | May 07, 2016
Proof-of-concept clinical trials on 20 patients in Indiaby Michael Cook | May 07, 2016
Overwhelmingly against germline modificationBioEdge
Suite 12A, Level 2 | 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615
Email: michael@bioedge.org
New Media Foundation | Level 2, 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | AUSTRALIA | +61 2 8005 8605
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario