|
“Fatherhood” is what the guys in the business of policing the language call an “essentially contested concept” – no matter how much palaver you invest in it, you won’t make any progress. At least nowadays.
Below we feature a story from the Netherlands about two men who have each sired over a hundred children, one through sperm donation to IVF clinics, the other mostly through more conventional channels. Are they fathers?
Another story comes from Australia, which is girding its loins for a campaign on same-sex marriage. A group promoting closer links between fathers and their children, Dads4Kids, has been running a public service TV advertisement for 15 years. This year, a 30-second spot of a dad crooning to his wee sprog was rejected because it was “too political”.
A spokesman for the foundation complained:
Happy Father’s Day to our Australian readers.
Below we feature a story from the Netherlands about two men who have each sired over a hundred children, one through sperm donation to IVF clinics, the other mostly through more conventional channels. Are they fathers?
Another story comes from Australia, which is girding its loins for a campaign on same-sex marriage. A group promoting closer links between fathers and their children, Dads4Kids, has been running a public service TV advertisement for 15 years. This year, a 30-second spot of a dad crooning to his wee sprog was rejected because it was “too political”.
A spokesman for the foundation complained:
“It is extraordinary that this is where we have come to as a country; we can no longer celebrate Father’s Day without being forced to look at it through the lens of the same-sex marriage debate. It’s a tragedy that a political motive is now implied in any mention of fatherhood. Not everything is about same-sex marriage.”
The history of this simple advertisement tracks the evolving concept. In a span of 15 years, fatherhood, or rather “fatherhood”, has shifted from a universally admired status to a politically suspect notion. Are we the better for it?Happy Father’s Day to our Australian readers.
Michael Cook
Editor BioEdge |
NEWS THIS WEEK | |
by Michael Cook | Sep 02, 2017
With 10,000 harmful single-gene mutations known, there is a lot at stake.
by Michael Cook | Sep 02, 2017
The real dimension of the killings by Niels Högel is likely many times worse, say police
by Michael Cook | Sep 02, 2017
A Father's Day story from the Netherlands
by Michael Cook | Sep 02, 2017
Harvard Medical School gets into the game
by Michael Cook | Sep 02, 2017
If more and more older women are seeking fertility treatment, this could be a big deal
by Xavier Symons | Sep 02, 2017
A provocative new journal article challenges conventional accounts of human death.
by Xavier Symons | Sep 02, 2017
How important is the label “vulnerable populations” in research ethics?
by Xavier Symons | Sep 02, 2017
How can we stop AI robots from becoming killing machines?
by Michael Cook | Sep 02, 2017
A prominent anti-vaccination campaigner has been barred from entering Australia.
BioEdge
Suite 12A, Level 2 | 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615
Email: michael@bioedge.org
|
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario